Distinguished Knoxville Attorneys
Complimentary Case Evaluations
Back to Top

Decoding Drag Bans: Is Drag a Crime?

The proposed bill has sparked controversy among the LGBTQ+ community in Tennessee and throughout the US. The bill, sponsored by state Sen. Janice Bowling (R-Tullahoma), would prohibit anyone under twenty-one from attending drag shows or any other performance similar to a drag show. The bill also targets transgender people by requiring minors seeking gender-affirming care to submit a letter from a medical provider in order to receive the treatment. Additionally, the bill would make it illegal for any elementary or middle school to provide LGBTQ+ education.

Understanding the Bill

Supporters of the bill claim that it is intended to protect minors and guard against "irresponsible behavior," while opponents argue that it limits freedom of expression and discriminates against the LGBTQ+ community. Specifically, transgender youth would be negatively impacted by the bill due to the requirement for a letter from a medical provider to receive gender-affirming care.

The Tennessee Equality Project has denounced the proposed bill and is working with attorneys at Lambda Legal to challenge it in court should it be passed into law. The Center for Transgender Equality (NCTE) has also spoken out against the bill, calling it "unconscionable" and stating that it would put transgender youth in danger by denying them access to potentially life-saving care.

The proposed bill is an example of how anti-LGBTQ+ laws can still be passed despite recent progress in LGBTQ+ rights. While it is still unclear if the bill will become law, it serves as an important reminder of the need to remain vigilant and continue fighting for equal rights for all LGBTQ+ people.

Anti-Trans Legislation and Criminalized Gender Expression

TN Governor Bill Lee signed a bill banning gender-affirming care into law this year. This law, which seeks to criminalize certain medical treatments for transgender youth would make it a Class A misdemeanor for physicians to perform any gender-affirming surgery or treatment on minors, including hormone therapy and puberty blockers.

The bill quickly sparked outrage from advocacy groups, who argue that denying medical treatment to transgender youth can be harmful and even life-threatening. Supporters of the bill argue that gender dysphoria is not a medical condition and that medical interventions can do more harm than good.

Since being signed into law, HB 2576 has received backing from several conservative organizations, including the Alliance Defending Freedom, which sees it as a necessary step to protect children from what they call "unproven and experimental medical procedures.” However, many medical professionals and advocacy groups have denounced the proposed law, stating that it could result in an increase in suicide rates among transgender youth.

Critics of the proposed law have also pointed out that it is a clear violation of transgender rights and autonomy. Transgender individuals have a right to make decisions about their own bodies and any attempt to restrict access to medical care is discriminatory.

The Youth Identity Protection Act is just one of many proposed bills throughout the country targeting transgender individuals. It is important that lawmakers respect the rights and dignity of transgender people and work towards creating a more inclusive society. Allowing transgender youth to access life-saving medical care is a critical step in achieving equality and promoting acceptance.

Key Takeaways

While both the drab ban and gender-affirming care law are in their early stages, it is important to understand the potential implications. The drag ban could result in misdemeanors and even felony charges for hosts and queens alike. The gender-affirming healthcare bill criminalizes treatments for transitioning minors and their parents. In either case, these bills could establish new crime categories and may pose a new threat to Tennesseans.

If you have been accused of a crime, contact Eldridge and Cravens, PC, and put your case in good hands.